.png){kind=small}
Case Studies / Animal Care Centers of NYC
CASE STUDY
Transforming Animal Advocacy Through Strategic Messaging
A Case Study of NYC's Largest Animal Shelter
Animal Care Centers of NYC stands as the largest animal organization in the Northeast, rescuing over 43,000 animals annually. As Associate Director of Communications, I transformed their messaging from crisis-driven appeals to professional, impact-focused communication that builds lasting donor relationships.
The Challenge
AC&C's messaging suffered from defensive, crisis-focused communication that overwhelmed potential supporters with institutional problems rather than inspiring action. Their appeals emphasized funding cuts, staff reductions, and operational struggles with language like "homeless, neglected, and abandoned animals, which have nowhere else to go, will directly benefit from your generosity."
This approach positioned supporters as rescuers of a failing system rather than partners in successful animal welfare work, creating donor fatigue and limiting long-term engagement potential.
Strategic Approach
I restructured AC&C's entire messaging framework around three core principles: solution-oriented communication that emphasized organizational strength, emotional engagement through success stories rather than crisis, and modernized digital communication strategies.
The transformation focused on shifting from deficit-based language to strength-based communication, positioning supporters as partners in success rather than emergency responders, and creating aspirational calls to action that celebrated community impact.
The Transformation
Before: "The homeless, neglected and abandoned animals, which have nowhere else to go, will directly benefit from your generosity of time, money and support. With more donations and more volunteers we can do a better job. Please join us today."
After: "Thank you for your interest in making a gift to Animal Care & Control of NYC! Gifts from our animal lovers, supporters, and friends are critical to our ability to continue our mission of providing the thousands of animals in our facilities with the daily care and compassion they deserve."
The messaging evolved from desperate institutional pleading to professional partnership communication with structured giving options and clear impact explanations.
Impact & Results
The messaging transformation delivered a 30% increase in revenue over three years and significantly improved donor retention rates. Most importantly, the strategic foundation I established continued to evolve after my departure, eventually leading to success-focused messaging like "13,650+ Lives Saved in 2024."
This demonstrates how strategic messaging transformation during critical periods creates lasting organizational change and sustainable growth frameworks.